Garden City Hotel

The Garden City Hotel is an overall excellent choice, and I always enjoy my stays here. I’ve stayed several times and plan to continue returning. The staff is truly outstanding, from the friendly front desk team to housekeeping, and the attentive doormen and bell staff. One of my favorite features of the suites is the leather-upholstered furniture, like the sofas. It’s a rare and elegant touch that adds to the comfort of the rooms. Additionally, the rooms are incredibly spacious, which I deeply appreciate. That said, there are a couple of areas where the hotel could improve. The bedside units are quite outdated, featuring USB ports alongside 30-pin dock connectors for older iPhones and iPods, which are no longer relevant. Updating these to modern charging stations would be a significant enhancement. Also, in rooms with combined bathtub and shower units, the shower curtains could be upgraded. Instead of the current ones, I’d love to see high-quality fabric curtains, like those found in other upscale hotels, which add a more refined and luxurious feel. Despite these minor points, I truly enjoy my time at this hotel and highly recommend it with these suggestions for improvement.

Old style luxury hotel with all amenities. Very well trained staff. First class service from arrival to departure. Rooms spacious. Well maintained facility. Substantially less expensive than an average hotel in midtown. When we were staying the LA hockey team was staying for a game with the Islanders. So well respected property. Town is walkable and quaint. Only complaint is overpriced breakfast buffet only w zero menu options

Very good hotel located at Garden City in NY. The hotel is a classic US hotel and offer spacious rooms, good restaurant, spa and fitness centre. Service is great and staff is welcoming and helpful. Downtown Manhattan could be easily reached in half hour through the rail transportation located just opposite the hotel.

20 friends and I enjoyed an elegant and festive holiday brunch on a cold Sunday morning. Our server, JC was the warmth that made the day unforgettable. He served special Bellinis and mimosas made with care and treated our whole group like queens. We will definitely be back for the delicious buffet and to see JC!

My husband and I came in from upstate NY to attend our neice's wedding. I was very impressed with the staff. There was always someone to open the door for us -- truly appreciated . The room - king size bed - was very clean and comfortable. I wish I had a mattress that comfortable!! I was midly annoyed when we arrived and couldn't check into our room until 4:45. The only complaint I have was that there was nowhere - save the small 'gift shop' - to get any snacks or drinks. Anyway, we will certainly stay at this hotel on our next visit to Long Island. highly recommend.