Montage Kapalua Bay

Resort location is wonderful, the paintbox program is wonderful and quality of food fantastic. Spa is wonderful. Variety of dining options/food & concierge service can greatly improve. Resort also feels slightly dated. Service across the board (other than valet & spa) is extremely slow. Concierge also does not go out of the way to enhance your stay as we visited for a week in a prime 3 bedroom ocean view residence we expected a bit more in service & hospitality

My wife and I spent 4 nights at the hotel in a one bedroom residence. There is much to like about this resort, but it also has limitations that should be understood. The property was originally developed as a Ritz Carlton club and residences in 2009 (which means condos), and was remodeled and rebranded as the Montage in 2014. It is a lovely property with great swimming pools. Because it was built as condos, all the units are large and really comfortable. Our one bedroom unit was huge and included a great kitchen, laundry facilities, and a big deck. There is a nice public beach at the edge of the property that allows you to bill your room for chairs and equipment. Maid service is twice per day, and really efficient and professional. The main restaurant, Canoe, is quite good and destination dining for the area (though be warned - you need reservations so plan in advance). The spa is one of the best things about the property. It is expensive, but it a beautiful facility with wonderful treatments. And the downsides.... I would not consider this a 5 star hotel, as it lacks the service and attention to detail. The entry lacks the grandeur of similar hotels, I think because it was built for condos. Service is very friendly, and everyone is doing their best, but it often feels understaffed and undertrained. When we checked in I had to explain to the woman at the desk that they were a member of Preferred Hotels. When we asked the concierge for assistance she referred us to a rack of brochures. Many of the poolside chairs are reserved for "residents" - I assume people own many of the units, and these chairs were mostly empty. Poolside service is very poor (it took 45 minutes to get a drink, so you end up getting it yourself). Food options are very limited. Aside from Canoe, the only other option is bar food. There is a nice bar next to the pool where you can order lunch, but the downside is that they store all their garbage next to the structure, and with the right breeze it smells like a sewer. The biggest issue is the construction. One of the towers is undergoing a complete renovation, and it is not only noisy but ugly to look at. Our deck looked out on a wrapped building, and they were unable to move us to a unit with a better view. While sitting at the pool you are treated to stereophonic cacophony, as it appeared one of the residents was remodeling with a jackhammer on one side, and the tower construction was on the other. Overall the energy of the place is more like a condo or timeshare development. There is not much going on at night, and many people go next door to the Ritz to enjoy more food options and a good bar and music scene. I think this is a good choice for people with kids that want big rooms (and there are a lot of kid activities), and are not looking for a lot of dining or cocktail options. Or it would also be good for people travelling in a group and want big rooms to entertain. The big kitchens and lack of dining options make it ideal for people that want to cook, but if cooking on your vacation is not your thing this hotel has drawbacks. A couple hints.... Try to get a room that does not look out on the construction. Make your reservations in advance, as they do not appear to give preferential treatment to hotel guests at Canoe. The best restaurant in the area, Merrimans, is walking distance from the hotel, but reserve far in advance.

Today is our last day after spending 10 here. The accommodations are amazing. Room is clean, comfortable and well supplied. Bed is super comfortable. Service is amazing all around - we lacked for nothing. The only complaint - there is MAJOR construction in progress, with one tower completely wrapped in tarps. On the other side, there is a remodel of a unit in progress. The entire time we have been here has been hammering and tile saw. It is LOUD! We just finished a major renovation at home, and are in the middle of a development that has had heavy construction for 6 days a week for the last year. We were specifically looking forward to being away from construction noise. For the money we spent to be here, the fact that it wasn’t disclosed anywhere is very disappointing. We were planning to rebook but will definitely discuss the renos with concierge prior. They were just out here looking at samples of pool tile also - and judging from the state of the pools and update is coming on those as well. Also keeping an eye on how the recent change in ownership will affect the Montage. After years of staying in VRBOs here, we are enjoying the splurge on the luxury and hope that it doesn’t change to more Holiday Inn accommodations. Finally, swim in the pool that connects with the one closest to ocean at your own risk. Despite common sense AND signage, we saw one family consistently swimming with littles without swim diapers. Get your chairs early in the adult more secluded areas or if you end up down at that deck, maybe don’t swim in that pool. Obviously not the hotels fault but just beware.

Our stay at Montage Kapalua Bay was nothing short of spectacular, and we are already planning our return! From the moment we arrived, the service was impeccable, and every staff member we encountered went above and beyond to make our trip unforgettable. Special shoutouts to Jeremy in the bar and restaurant, who brought warmth and incredible energy to every interaction. His drink recommendations and attention to detail truly elevated our dining experience. Eric, the poolside server, was phenomenal—always friendly, attentive, and ensuring we were well taken care of. Stacy in guest services was a delight, providing seamless assistance with everything we needed. And Lisa? She makes the best coffee we’ve ever had! She turned every morning into the perfect start to our day. The valet and hotel drivers deserve major recognition as well. They were consistently friendly, polite, and prompt. Every time we called for the hotel car, it arrived with a smile, and we never had to wait. Housekeeping was equally outstanding—thorough, efficient, and always with a kind word. One standout moment was when Sally and the chef graciously accommodated our family of nine with a custom grill pack on incredibly short notice, even on a day when he was managing a large wedding. The food was phenomenal, and his flexibility and professionalism were greatly appreciated. The in-room dining team also exceeded expectations, though I regret not catching the name of the fantastic attendants who took such great care of us. The Cliff House experience was another highlight—breathtaking views, the perfect sunset, and sipping Veuve as we watched whales from the balcony was a memory we’ll treasure forever. While everything was world-class, I do have one suggestion: implementing a no-holding-chairs policy at the pool. It was frustrating to walk around with nowhere to sit while so many chairs were empty but “reserved.” At a luxury property like this, guests should always feel they have access to seating. Finally, though there was a miscommunication with our cabana rental on the first day, Montage more than made it right for us. Their exceptional customer service ensured we left with nothing but glowing memories. Thank you to the Montage Kapalua Bay team for an unforgettable vacation. You’ve set the bar high for luxury and hospitality!

We had a great stay at the Montage with 9 people - 4 adults and 5 kids ages 11-16. We booked our room directly through a villa owner and had a great bunk room for all the kids and 2 master suites. Having a laundry room and full kitchen in the villa was amazing! The property is lovely and the staff were amazing. We were there over Christmas break and had to reserve chairs at 7am everyday, but I think that is only for that week. The staff said they’ve never seen it that busy before. The pools are amazing - the kids had a blast. The staff there is very low-key and really give the kids free rein. The water is heated to 79 so not too hot and still refreshing when you jump in. And the pools don’t close so you can swim any time of day, which the kids loved. There are lots of waitstaff at the pool and we had plenty of drinks and lunch at the pool everyday. Kelsey and Anu were wonderful servers at the pool. The beach is about a 5-7 minute walk. Our kids who usually love to boogie board and snorkel and be in the ocean didn’t want to go to it. It’s very rocky and not sand once you get in the water. If you want a beach vacation this is not the place. Every night the adults went to the Hideaway for cocktails after dinner and loved the vibe there. It’s also a great spot for a casual dinner - we ate here one night and it was good. Jeremy the bartender took very good care of us - I don’t think I’ve ever seen another person work as hard as he did that week. We ate off-property every night except 1 night at Cane and Canoe and 1 night for room service. We did not have a good experience at Cane and Canoe for dinner, but the F&B Manager apologized and went out of his way to make it right. Our breakfast at Cane and Canoe was decent. Would highly-recommend Montage for a family vacation. I wouldn’t pick it for a couple’s trip/honeymoon since it’s more family-focused, but that may just because we were there during Christmas and there were 7 million kids. The staff, the pool, the views, and the villa accommodations make it a great family spot. Also, the amount of off-property dining within 10 minutes (car) is amazing. We will definitely be back.