Baglioni Resort Cala del Porto 

My husband and I have just spent 5 fantastic nights at this stunning hotel. We had spent a busy tour visiting Florence, Siena, La Spezia and Cinq Terre. We were very ready to relax and be pampered and we certainly were at this gorgeous hotel. We stayed in a standard room which was beautifully decorated and had fabulous high quality furnishing/fabrics and bedlinen. If you are able to afford a sea view I think it would be well worth it. The decor through the entire hotel is so calming and beautiful. The staff are all wonderful, polite and friendly. Everyone from the managers to the waiters and cleaners. The outside pool area is also fabulous with lovely loungers and beautiful towels provided. Breakfast is plentiful with a good variety of continental and cooked options. Cooked breakfasts are freshly cooked and brought to your table. We ate twice in the restaurant and it was delicious. We were a little surprised to discover that all the beaches were private and the cost was €40 per day (incl loungers and parasol) however we found a quiet beach nearby where we managed to find a public area to have our daily swim and then return to the stunning pool area to sunbathe. As has been said this is a quiet area and definitely not for partygoers! After our busy tour it proved absolutely perfect for us. We found several lovely walks and also enjoyed browsing the beautiful yachts in the nearby marina. There are a few shops and restaurants in the marina area and we enjoyed several good/cheaper meals here too. Thank you for a super holiday, we highly recommend.

The rooms are comfortable, views are exquisite and the pool was very relaxing but, the location is a touch limiting. We had a lovely relaxing time, but my child (6yro) was a little bored by the end of our time. The hotel is gorgeous and the staff really do want to help, I just felt that the location was a bit lacking. they didn't inform us though of a close by water park or kids club which could have been helpful. We felt that any day excursions were very expensive and best to have access to a car if staying here.

Stayed here for a few days whilst going to see Andrea Boccelli which was an hour and a half drive away from Theatro Di Silenzio. What a beautiful hotel this is . So pretty and with wonderful staff, food and service. The views of the Marina below are breathtaking. The food in the hotel was excellent and there were lovely restaurants bars and upmarket shops to visit in the Marina below which was a 10 minute walk away.

There is nothing to do in this remote corner of Tuscany. The staff could not care less about your stay, they did not show you the way to the pool or restaurant. The beach is a 15 minute shuttle to the beach which is NOT private and the pool is freezing. The restaurant is overpriced and the food is cold. The rooms are tiny and have mild in them. The concierge can’t give one decent suggestion. Simple. DO NOT COME HERE.

A very expensive and beautiful hotel set in a unique location above the marina in Punta Ala overlooking the island of Elba. It would appear that the area is attracting many Russians who are very demanding and I would be unlikely to stay here in high season The food quality is excellent but very expensive and local restaurants offer better value.